What
the documentary Saving Face and The House is Black
had in common was that they both made me uncomfortable and extremely sad.
Though they were of two places in the Middle East, the two were very different
in that acid attacks are something humans created and that’s just disgusting.
Being American born, but of Pakistani origin it was hard for me to establish a
sort of prejudice for the people in Pakistan. It’s not as if people there are bad
and it would be expected that I run to my “country’s” defense, but I just can’t. The film just helps showcase how much a male
dominant culture Pakistani women have to live in and it’s just not fair. All
the husbands and offenders in that documentary were just pathetic excuses for
human beings. How dare they think better of themselves, how dare they think
they had the right to ruin the lives of their wives. They weren’t possessions,
but I suppose that’s the kind of belief dowries ensure. “I’m paying you to marry my daughter” so
essentially you just bought her. It’s not the women’s fault at all and though
the blame lies with the offender, I feel that part of it belongs to the women’s
families. They had arranged marriages, most forced, and it’s like signing off
on their death sentence. They may have not been in those situations in the
first place had not been for that. If I
had not already known of both the country and acid attacks I would most
definitely have formed a harsh opinion of Pakistan. You can’t blame all the
people residing in a country for its problems, but you can blame them for not
stopping them, for not trying hard enough to prevent them. It’s not as if I
hate the people in Pakistan, it’s just that I hate that such horrible arrogant
people exist, no matter where they are in world.
It’s reminiscent of rape in the military. Who’s going to
believe the woman over the man? The military had been male dominant for so long;
it’s hard to get rid of that standard. These crimes much like the acid attacks
take so long to processes and by then women are far worse in their suffering.
Also the military has to take extra precautions to prove the crime, as to not
falsely damage its reputation. Even if they get their justice, the women still
have the emotional and physical scars. It’s scary to think that such things
could happen to anyone, and yet to see the women with burnt faces behave so
normally, to laugh, to smile was heartwarming. That they had such courage and
willed themselves to keep on living was just wondrous.
A particular part of the documentary that really stuck out
to me was when the doctor told the daughter of one his patients that she had
her mom back that she was lost for a little while, but she’s back. The surgery did give her the confidence to
face the world, but the statement really made me question beauty, the face, and
what it means to us as humans. It’s so important to us to be beautiful, to look
nice, and to be liked and they all seem like such trivial things when you look
at the rest of the world. We are defined by the way we look, our face, and to
take that away is to take away our identities. But I wonder, is the face really as important
as we think it is? Sure the face is an important part of us, but it’s not our
mind, the mind that tells us what’s supposed to beautiful, what’s supposed to
have importance. Aren't we really just
our minds hidden behind a face that society determines is good enough or not?
It's interesting how the face is important in so many cultures. It's not just in America or Pakistan. When we see a face that is "disfigured" the mind can't help but wonder what happened. It's sad to me that this is such a focus in many cultures. You would think that we could find a way to move past it but so many of our experiences in life are based solely on the way you look. Sometimes it will be the deciding factor on whether someone will get a job or not. It's crazy!
ReplyDeleteHina,
ReplyDeleteI think your cultural understanding must make injustices that much harder to bear. But let me ask, if you think the violence is a result of arranged marriages and women not having more of a say, and being 'sold' to a man, why, in the U.S., where women have freedom of choice and are not 'sold' per se to a man, are so many women murdered by their boyfriends/husbands? (I posted stats about this, when I commented on Keleigh's blog post.)
I think male domination is still everywhere; violence is still everywhere. How do we try to change this? Maybe your final project could take on such a question? Just an idea!
Spring