I definitely noticed similarities between The House is Black and Saving Face. Both of these films were
more like documentaries about tragic problems in the Middle East. The people in
the films were tragically altered physically by these conflicts. In a way both
of these groups of people were forced to live this life. The burned victims
were attacked by family members and had no control of the situation. The
leprosy victims were shunned and forced to leave which only worsened their
mental and physical state. These victims did not like their appearance and both
groups took steps to make themselves better. The acid victims got plastic
surgery and the leprosy victims got physical therapy and other medical
procedures. They were both showing signs of being ashamed at the way they
appeared. The women looked in the mirror at her face taken over by disease and
could not recognize herself. The woman in the acid film used to love taking
pictures but no longer did once she was burned. Lastly, in both documentaries
there were individuals who accepted their situation and even reached out to others
with the same problems. They helped keep one another’s hopes up.
From an American perspective I was shocked by what I saw. I
never realized that the laws and court system were so bad in the Middle East. They
did nothing to help women and most men walked free on all charges. I also did
not realize that a woman could be a lawyer in the Middle East and be taken
seriously. I thought women were forced to be submissive and in the background.
This was also why I was shocked at how vain the women could be. They genuinely cared
about their appearance even though they cover much of their bodies. They joked
around and painted their nails. They have the same attachments to their
children that we in America do. This shocked me because I always saw them as
being strict and not emotional. They did not seem to ever spoil their children
or show motherly love. However, in the film I saw a bit of that.
I think it is hard to respect another culture if you do not
have an open mind. You need to be willing to see situations from other
perspectives and viewpoints. I think we as Americans can be so closed minded
and opinionated that we do not allow others to explain their views or
reasoning. We can only respect others if we learn why they do what they do and
how it appeals to their lifestyle. We may not like their views or agree with
them, but we have to accept that these are their customs.
Kelsey,
ReplyDeleteWhat you write makes me think that you are finding more commonalities between women across borders than maybe you'd thought existed. You might want to think about this as we enter into the next phase of this course in which I will be asking everyone to think about final projects. What if you made a film in which you interviewed a woman (or several women) who did not grow up in the U.S., but lives here now? (Just an idea!)
Best,
Spring