Many
things disturbed me while watching Dariush Mehrjui’s film adaptation of The Cow but as Hamid Dabash pointed out
in his article, the film is a work with an uncanny nature. Even the
opening credits inform the audience that what they are about to see will not be
a typical film. Shapes appear that
resemble a man and a cow, but these shapes are fluid. They are not strict outlines of a man or
animal; they are like watching a mirage in the distance and never quite come
into focus. This choice for the opening
credits made much more sense to me once I realized the character Hassan had
such a close relationship with his cow and when he eventually goes mad and
mentally transforms into his prized animal.
I was very stuck by the bond between man and beast as well as the actions
of the villagers. The uncompassionate attitude
of the village is displayed in the opening scene when a mentally challenged man
is being tortured by the children and Saffar’s son, a young man who has come
back from the city. This scene is later
replicated when Hassan loses his grasp on reality but the lack of empathy and
compassion amongst the humans only contributed to illustrating how significant Hassan’s
relationship is with his cow. Another aspect that made me feel uncomfortable
was the lack of any sort of relationship between Hassan and his wife. His wife clearly knows that her husband
values a cow much more than he values her; this fact definitely made an impact
on me. Unlike Dabash I didn’t find
solace in this intense bond between Hassan and the cow, because of the flagrant
disregard that was shown towards human begins throughout the film. Perhaps that was the point. Perhaps Mehrjui meant to force the audience
to confront the lack of human consideration by showing how much a man can love
an animal and if anything that human beings tend to treat each other like
beasts.
Maybe this is why Mehrjui chose to have the scenes with the villagers being unkind to it's outcasts. It makes it easier for the viewer to empathize with Hasaan who finds it difficult to socialize with anyone besides his cow. i also found Hassan's treatment of the cow a little disturbing and very sad. He felt so alone with other people that he could only relate to a cow...a being that couldn't actually empathize with him.
ReplyDeleteYour point about human beings treating each other like beasts reminds me of Lord of the flies. The strong or bigger group of peeople will pray on those that are different(weak).