Throughout the course of the film Black Girl by Ousmane Sembene, a roller coaster of emotions were
displayed, much like that of anyone. We have all been in a situation where we
got really excited and then were let down and eventually turned to anger. For an
extremely less meaningful and dramatic example, many people out of college go job
hunting and try their best to get one related to their major but this doesn’t always
happen. After a few weeks of trying, most people just want a job no matter the
sort. The day they are accepted everything is filled with smiles and excitement,
until they work for a few months and realize they hate their job. At this point
people become miserable, less productive, and have no motivation to work
anymore. This is what happened to Diouana but in a much more dramatic way.
Once Diouana
started to be mistreated by her French owners and constantly being told where
her race and place were aloud, she became isolated and depressed. Every day was
the same out lifeless routine that only ended up with her feeling more and more
desperate to get out of this expensive hell. As the days continued to linger
on, she finally cracked and stood up for herself by not doing any more work – Diouana
was done. I really enjoyed how Sembene built up the aggression but having Diouana
become sad, then miserable, then sluggish and unmotivated, to standing up for
herself. This showed a very natural expression to a misleading situation.
Unfortunately, after this scene is where I became disappointed. I did not agree
with the expedited timeline to her death. I felt as though a lot of time was
missing and it was a quick jump. My suggestions would be to either show a few
days of things getting worse, attempts to leave France but was denied freedom home,
or even Diouana standing up for herself verbally and told the owners how she
really felt. At least if she made an attempt to get away it would have seemed
more realistic to me. I do appreciate the silent death and creating a ‘mess’
that the owners have to clean up, as if it is a taste of their own medicine, I
just think it could have been done in a better way.
Jamie,
ReplyDeleteI totally agree with your suggestions for a better ending to the film. I too felt that the suicide scene was just too abrupt. The film was just short of an hour, there was more time for Sembene to expand upon how Diouana could have freed herself, yet he chose not to. I am sure this was purposeful, yet some audiences, like ourselves, would have probably appreciated more of an explanation of the events leading up to the suicide, rather than such a sudden ending.